On last night

There are a million people writing great things on the Internet today about last night. I’m going to tell a story:

I was sitting in a bar in Boston — I think it was the Beacon Hill Pub —  a year or two after I got out of college, maybe 2001. It was a late afternoon in August, and I was with a bunch of buddies, just hanging out.  The bar was almost empty, and everyone there was watching the Red Sox game. It was a pretty standard mostly-empty-bar baseball crowd.  Two patrons in particular, however, stuck out. The first was a man who must have been about 60. He was sitting alone at the end of the bar, wearing a red sweatshirt, and quietly muttering “fuck the Yankees” over and over again while he drank his beer. (Note: the Red Sox were not playing the Yankees on the TV).

Given his age, I made up a back story in my head for him: he was probably 6 years old when Pesky held the ball in the ’46 Series and 8 when they dumped the 1-game playoff to the Indians, and then spent the rest of his youth watching the Yankees win a dozen pennants and a pile of World Series. It was that kind of formative baseball experience that would produce this kind of 60-year-old. And my own experience agreed: my first vivid memory of the baseball playoffs was the ’86 Series, when I was 8. I’m sitting with my dad watching game 6 — we’re yankees fans, so obviously we’re rooting for the Mets — and when Stanley throws the wild pitch, my father — who up to this moment had been dead quiet —  just starts laughing hysterically. And then I do to. And then Buckner and now we’re both roaring again, uncontrollably. And then Strawberry hits that towering cheery-on-top-of-the-sundae homer in the 8th inning of game 7 and we both start laughing again. And to this day, whenever something goes wrong for the Red Sox, I start laughing. So I understand how these things happen.

The other guy of note in the bar, my friends and I actually talked to him. Another Red Sox fan, huge Boston accent. He had a childhood baseball story too. Turns out he was 7 years old during the ’75 Series. And it also turns out that he never really got over it. It was all he wanted to talk about. He quizzed us on the Reds’ starting lineup (we got everyone but Cesar Geronimo), he recounted in detail his living room reaction to the Armbrister/Fisk non-interference call in game 3, he told us about Tiant’s complete game in game 4. And then he started to talk about game 6. After a short monologue he says, “You guys know who hit the big home run in that game, right?” And one of us says, “yeah, Carlton Fisk.” And he then instantly answered with a firm “No! That’s what everyone says. But the answer is Bernie Carbo! His homer in the 8th was the important one. That’s when I knew the Sox were going to win the game, and the Series!” And then we sat in silence for a few seconds. Finally, one of my buddies says, “Yeah? So what happened in game 7?” And the guy looks straight at us and says, “That’s what I’m still trying to figure out.” And then he walked away.

Somewhere in Boston, there’s a kid who’s going to spend the rest of his life trying to figure out what the hell happened last night.

Five other quick thoughts, hopefully not duplicating anything you’ve read already today:

3) The Sox collapse is like a microcosm of all their great tragedies. The month-long nature of it makes it  a lot like ’78. So does Dan Johnson’s Dent-ish homer. Crawford’s non-catch in left field is reminiscent of Pesky/Stanley/Buckner. The two easy outs in the 9th were very ’86 Game 6ish.  Longoria’s homer was very Boone-ish ’03.  Add in that the Yankees were involved — by losing — and that just sends it into the stratosphere.

1) Dan Johnson is like Bucky Dent crossed with Bernie Carbo. No way that homer happened. I mean, Johnson makes Dent look like a triple-crown contender. “That little shit hit a god damn 300 foot pop-fly.” That’s Tip O’neil, in his autobiography, talking about Dent’s homer. He might as well have been talking about Johnson.  But I bet, like Carbo, he ends up taking a back seat in our memories in the coming years. Longoria’s game-winner is going to be the iconic clip.

2) Last night wasn’t possible ten years ago. The fan experience is just different now. I had all three game available to me on my TV, which itself probably wouldn’t have been possible in the 90’s. But Twitter took those games through the roof. Maybe there have been Twitter sports moments before, but last night was the first time I felt like I was watching the games with dozens of other people, despite sitting alone on my couch. I remember watching game 5 of the 2004 ALCS (the 14-inning marathon at Fenway) alone in my apartment, in the dark, barely blinking. A totally different feeling (no doubt, in part,  because I was rooting for the Yankees), and an amazing one in its own right. But had Twitter existed then, I’m pretty sure it would have made it even better (worse).

4) Baseball drama is more rare, but much more satisfying, than any other sports drama. As plenty of people have said over the years, it’s partly because of the lack of clock. You get these great closeups of the pitcher reading the signs, the batter digging in, the runner leading off first. But you never know exactly when the action is going to start. And then the pitch is way outside and the tension is released and starts building again. But I also think it’s because of the one-on-one confrontations. Yes, it’s a team game, but the success and failure is individual. And I think that makes us relate to it differently. It’s more personal.

5) There’s no cosmic justice for baseball. How else could Tampa make that comeback last night with less than 30k fans coming out to the park? That’s just embarrassing.

As for me, I tweeted the follwoing about 45 minutes before it all ended:  Whether the Sox blow this tonight or tomorrow or at Daddy stadium in the ALCS, it’s going to be wonderful history to watch. Which it was. And, yes, I stayed true to form: after Papelbon gave up the tying run I started involuntarily giggling. And then when Crawford dropped the ball, I started uncontrollably laughing. This being the 21st century, I followed that up with a tweet 15 seconds later: hahahahahaha.

Share

2 thoughts on “On last night

  1. John

    In one major way, this Red Sox team was very different than all the other ones you’ve mentioned above because a lot of people in Boston really dislike this team; by the end, I was half hoping for them to fail as a form of just desserts. Overpaid/underperforming free agents like Lackey, Crawford, DiceK, Drew, etc. made this a very non-likeable team (which is too bad, because other players like Ellsbury and Aceves had great years). Put another way, 99% of baseball fans of other teams had to be rooting for the Rays, right? They are far more-likable as a group of players, attendance at home games notwithstanding.

    I went to the final home game of the year, and after watching them piss away another lead, by the time Sweet Caroline came around in the middle of the 8th, I couldn’t take it any more and just started yelling, “Stop it, you lemmings! You should be booing this team to the hilt not singing a stupid song!” This sentiment was not well met by the drunken pink hats, but several obviously-grizzled Sox-lifers gave me knowing nods.

    In some weird way, this Sox collapse has me thinking about the 2008 Patriots, the year that Brady went down in game 1. That was the last time I fully enjoyed the regular season following my team, as there was real meaning to each game, a sense that each game is important, and of being an underdog. I haven’t had that with the Sox in awhile, and that’s too bad.

    I just hope the Rays beat the Yankees in the ALCS, so NYY fans can question the wisdom of not pitching Rivera in the 9th when they had a chance to, potentially, keep the Rays out of the playoffs.

    Reply
    1. Matt Post author

      I agree. One thing I’ve spent a lot of time talking to people about in the last few weeks is how much baseball “fandom” has changed in New York and Boston since 2004. It’s got a little bit of that Philly post-1980 feel to it, where they finally won and everyone just kinda moved on with their lives, but that’s not exactly it. But it’s part of it: there’s so much less intensity to the Yanks/Sox thing. MLB devised the wild-card system with enhancing that rivalry in mind, and they got their wish in a wonderful crescendo during the ’99, ’03, and ’04 playoffs. But the air has definitely come out of the balloon now that the Sox are 2-time champs with a less desperate fan base. Another part of it is the desertion of the Sox by many of their casual boom-time fans; it looks more like the old fan base, just without the bitterness and hope/despair. Ditto in NY — the Red Sox rivalry fueled so much of the early 00’s that I feel like the fanbase is a bit lost now. And the new stadium doesn’t help.

      Related, I was thinking how wonderful the 2003 ALCS and NLCS were — probably the best 10 days of baseball in my life (maybe the ’86 WS compares, but nothing else), and how it really hasn’t been even close to that since the end of ’04. The Bartman 30/30 earlier this week brought it all back form me, a great film and a great time period in baseball. A heyday I didn’t even realize at the time.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *